By Roy Thomas, Gerry Conway, John Buscema, Ross Andru, Ramona Fradon, Rich Buckler, Joe Sinnott, Frank Giacoia & various (MARVEL)
ISBN 978-1-3029-3359-3 (TPB/Digital edition)
Win’s Christmas Gift Recommendation: Fantastic Festive Fun… 8/10
Cautiously bi-monthly and cover-dated November 1961, Fantastic Four #1 (by Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, George Klein & Christopher Rule) was raw and crude even by the ailing company’s standards: but it seethed with rough, passionate and uncontrolled excitement. Thrill-hungry kids pounced on its dynamic storytelling and caught a wave of change starting to build in America. It and succeeding issues changed comics forever.
As seen in the groundbreaking premier issue, maverick scientist Reed Richards, his fiancée Sue Storm, their close friend Ben Grimm and Sue’s bratty teenaged brother survived an ill-starred private space-shot after Cosmic Rays penetrated their ship’s inadequate shielding.
All permanently mutated: Richards’ body became elastic, Sue became (even more) invisible, and Johnny Storm burst into living flame whilst tragic Ben shockingly devolved into a shambling, rocky freak. After the initial revulsion and trauma passed, they solemnly agreed to use their abilities to benefit mankind. Thus was born The Fantastic Four.
Throughout the 1960s it was indisputably the key title and most consistently groundbreaking series of Marvel’s ever-unfolding web of cosmic creation: a forge for new concepts and characters. Kirby was in his creative prime: continually unleashing his vast imagination on plot after spectacular plot, whilst Lee scripted some of the most passionate superhero sagas ever seen.
Both were on an unstoppable roll, at the height of their powers and full of the confidence only success brings, with The King particularly eager to see how far the genre and the medium could be pushed… which is rather ironic since it was the company’s reticence to give the artist creative freedom which led to Kirby’s jumping ship to National/DC in the first place…
And then, he was gone…
With this collection of “The World’s Greatest Comics Magazine” a new style was confirmed. Without Kirby’s soaring imagination the rollercoaster of mind-bending High Concepts had given way to more traditional tales of characters in conflict, with soap-opera leanings and super-villain-dominated Fights ‘n’ Tights dramas.
This cunning compilation re-presents Fantastic Four #126-146 and Giant-Size Super-Stars #1: collectively covering September 1972 to May 1974, which saw Roy Thomas assume the role of writer/editor. He began by revisiting the classic origin and first clash with The Mole Man from FF #1. Illustrated by John Buscema & Joe Sinnott, ‘The Way it Began!’ was all mere prelude for what was to follow…
The reverie prompts the Thing to invade the sub-surface despot’s realm in search of a cure for the blindness which afflicts his girlfriend Alicia Masters in ‘Where the Sun Dares Not Shine!’ and all too soon the embattled brute is embroiled in a three-way war between Mole Man, Kala – Empress of the Netherworld and immortal dictator Tyrannus. When his comrades go after Ben, they are duped into attacking him in ‘Death in a Dark and Lonely Place!’…
Having barely survived the three-way war, the exhausted team return to their Baxter Building HQ just in time for lovesick, heartsore Johnny to leave for the hidden kingdom of Attilan and explosively confront lost love – and Inhuman Princess – Crystal.
Tragically as he leaves, ‘The Frightful Four… Plus One!’ sees the Thing ambushed by The Sandman, Wizard and Trapster, beside their newest and almost uncontrollable ally… super-strong amazon Thundra.
Happily, Crystal’s sister Medusa is there to pitch in as the clash escalates, spreading to ‘Battleground: The Baxter Building!’ wherein infant Franklin Richards begins exhibiting terrifying abilities. Always and literally left holding the baby and fed up with her husband’s neglect, Susan finally leaves Reed, whilst in the Himalayas, Johnny has forced his way to Crystal’s side only to find his worst nightmares realised…
Fantastic Four #131 describes a ‘Revolt in Paradise!’ (illustrated by Ross Andru & Sinnott) as Crystal, her new fiancé Quicksilver, and the rest of the Inhumans are attacked by their genetically-bred and programmed slave-race the Alpha Primitives. At first it seems that insane usurper Maximus is again responsible for the strife, but a deeper secret lurks behind the deadly danger of ‘Omega! The Ultimate Enemy!’, and only when the rest of the FF arrive does Reed ferret it out…
FF #133 celebrated the holiday season with plenty of fireworks in ‘Thundra at Dawn!’ as the mysterious “Femizon” returns to battle Ben once more, courtesy of incoming scripter Gerry Conway, guest penciller Ramona Fradon & Sinnott, after which ‘A Dragon Stalks the Sky!’ in #134 (Conway, Buscema & Sinnott) finds Reed, Johnny, Ben and Medusa fighting forgotten super-rich foe Gregory Gideon and his latest acquisition Dragon Man: a bombastic battle which concludes in a struggle to possess ‘The Eternity Machine’…
The secret of that reality-warping device is revealed in a two-part thriller as cosmic entity Shaper of Worlds creates a horrific paranoid pastiche of 1950s America: re-running the conflicts between rebellious youth and doctrinaire, paternalistic authority in ‘Rock Around the Cosmos!’ and the surreal conclusion ‘Rumble on Planet 3’ which also tapped into the then-ongoing struggles of the Civil Rights movement…
In amongst the sub-plots, the never-ending stress had forced Sue Richards away from her husband but their son’s rapidly-growing, undiagnosed cosmic powers and problems were pulling them reluctantly back together…
Mr. Fantastic was not taking the separation well and #138 finds him left in an increasingly depressive state when old comrade Wyatt Wingfoot comes looking for assistance against impossible, unimaginable disasters. ‘Madness is… The Miracle Man!’ began a period when rocky everyman Ben Grimm became de facto star of the Fantastic Four and here he, the Torch and Medusa travel to Wingfoot’s tribal lands in Oklahoma to battle a cheesy hypnotist first encountered in their third adventure…
Now, however, thanks to the charlatan’s subsequent studies under mystic Cheemuzwa medicine men, the maniac actually can reshape reality with a thought…
The battle concluded in ‘Target: Tomorrow!’ with the villain able to control matter but not himself spiralling frantically out of control, with our heroes struggling indomitably on until the Miracle Man makes a fatal, world-threatening error…
Reed’s travails take a darker turn in Fantastic Four # 140 as ‘Annihilus Revealed!’ finds the insectoid tyrant king of dying antimatter universe the Negative Zone kidnapping the ever-more powerful Franklin as a prelude to invading the Baxter Building in search of new worlds to ravage.
In triumph, the bug horror discloses his incredible origin to the helpless Wingfoot before dragging all his enemies back to his subspace hell to engineer ‘The End of the Fantastic Four!’ However, even though the beaten heroes counterattack and gain an unlikely victory, Annihilus’ prior tampering with Franklin triggers a cosmic catastrophe. As his limitless power spikes out of control, his tormented father is compelled to blast the boy, shutting down his mutant brain …and everything else.
Appalled at the callous cold calculations needed to put his own son into a coma, Johnny and Ben join Sue in deserting the grief-stricken Mr. Fantastic and declaring their heroic partnership defunct.
With only ruthlessly pragmatic Medusa remaining, FF #142 sees shell-shocked Richards with ‘No Friend Beside Him!’ (as Conway and inker Sinnott were joined by new artist Rich Buckler, whose faithful pastiche of Jack Kirby produced a wave of favourable nostalgia in fans then and now) whilst the Thing follows long-time girlfriend Alicia Masters to central Europe.
She has been lured to the Balkans with promises of a medical breakthrough that can cure her blindness, but once Ben arrives, they are promptly attacked by a sinister supernatural horror named Darkoth the Death-Demon…
Back in the USA, Johnny and Wyatt Wingfoot head for Metro College to see their old sports coach Sam Thorne on his way to an Alumni reunion. Reed is another attendee, despondently dragged there by Medusa, but nobody expects that weird foreign kid who had been expelled so long ago to turn up, leading to ‘The Terrible Triumph of Doctor Doom!’ (inked by Frank Giacoia)…
The Iron Dictator was never one to forgive a slight, real or imagined, and as he gloatingly reveals himself to be the creator of Darkoth and jailer of the Thing, Victor von Doom further boasts to his captives of his latest scheme… to utterly eradicate human free will.
Typically, though, the tyrant hasn’t considered how his death-demon might react to the news that he is sham. Outraged the puppet rebels and the monster’s ‘Attack!’ (#144 by Buckler & Sinnott) results in a cataclysmic clash and Doom’s defeat…
Back together but still disunited, the FF part company again in #145, with Johnny accompanying Medusa to the Himalayan citadel of Attilan – hidden city of the Inhumans – only to be brought down by a lost race of ice people and forced to endure a ‘Nightmare in the Snow!’ (illustrated by Andru & Sinnott). Here, snow troglodytes’ plans to make Earth into an ice-ball only they can inhabit go bizarrely awry as the Thing joins the frozen heroes. When a dissident faction trained by a Buddhist monk also pitch in, the conclusion is a happy ending all round in ‘Doomsday: 200 Below!’
This was period of great experimentation and expansion at Marvel, with new formats and lines launching seemingly continuously. Giant-Size Super-Stars #1 (May 1974) was a forerunner in a line of supplementary, double-length titles starring the company’s most popular stars.
In this initial exploratory outing – the title became Giant-Size Fantastic Four with the second quarterly release – Conway, Buckler & Sinnott crafted ‘The Mind of the Monster!’: a shattering reprise of earlier titanic team-up triumphs beginning when Bruce Banner came calling upon the FF, still seeking a cure for his mean green alter ego. Unfortunately, the Thing is overly sympathetic, and in his self-loathing foolishly allows the fugitive physicist to modify one of Reed’s devices…
Unfortunately, meddling with the Psi-Amplifier switches their minds, leaving the Rampaging Hulk trapped and furiously running amok in the Thing’s body whilst Ben/Hulk struggles to stop him.
The situation plummets into more chaos when trans-dimensional Femizon Thundra pitches in, mistakenly believing she is helping her intended main squeeze Ben battle a big green monster, with violence intensifying to the max when Reed, Johnny and Medusa get involved in second chapter ‘Someone’s Been Sleeping in My Head’…
Ultimately it takes everybody and a cunning plan to set the world to rights in the spectacular, full-throated conclusion ‘…And in This Corner: The Incredible Hulk!’
Following a bunch of editorial extras from the special, a few last treats complement the covers throughout (by Buscema, Gil Kane, Giacoia, Buckler, Jim Steranko and John Romita). These include a selection of contemporary house ads, the cover of all-reprint Fantastic Four Annual #10 and extracts from F.O.O.M. #1 (Spring 1973): the Steranko cover, intro article ‘Once Upon a FOOM!’, contemporary bios of the Marvel Bullpen, a reproduction of the cover to FF#1 plus attendant article ‘When Titans Clash!’; a checklist of FF issues; a pin-up of FF #73; a Doctor Doom game, Thomas, Len Brown, Gil Kane & Wally Wood’s Fantastic Fear pastiche from Not Brand Echh; Kirby’s Doctor Doom cover from F.O.O.M. #4; ‘Quotations from Chairman Doom’; Charley Parker’s ‘Dr Foom’, and board game ‘Heavy Conflict!’
Also recovered are Buckler & Sinnott’s Thing cover from F.O.O.M. #5, more ‘Marvel Bullpen Profiles’, ‘Marvel’s Greatest Hero: The Thing’ plus uncorrected cover art for FF #130 & 131 and original art pages by Buscema, Buckler & Sinnott.
Although Kirby had taken the unmatched imagination and questing sense of wonder with him on his departure, the sheer range of beloved characters and concepts he had created with Stan Lee carried the series for years afterwards. So once writers who shared the originators’ sensibilities were crafting the stories a mini-renaissance began…
This period offers fans a tantalising taste of the glory days and these solid, honest and intriguing efforts will be welcomed by dedicated superhero fans and continuity freaks alike. They will also thrill and enthral the casual browser looking for an undemanding slice of graphic narrative excitement, so what’s stopping you?
© 2022 MARVEL.